How do I choose a TikTok Shop agency?

“Last month 15 different brands told us they got screwed by their TikTok Shop agency.”

I shared a framework for avoiding that fate: verify the agency’s differentiator, interview the account manager who will actually work your account, and confirm they publish credible thought leadership on the channel.

Why most brands pick the wrong agency partner

The pattern I see is straightforward: brands sign contracts without asking the right questions.

“Most of the times these brands just don’t know the correct questions to ask.”

Agencies look similar on the surface—case studies, creator networks, technology claims. The difference shows up after the contract is signed, when the day-to-day operator determines whether the brand wins or loses.

What valid differentiators actually look like

I outlined three concrete differentiators worth verifying:

“Proprietary in house tech trained on historical data for TikTok Shop fulfillment. An in house engaged creator community with at least 2-300 creators for your niche. A case study in the last 90 days for a brand of your size and niche.”

If an agency cannot point to at least one of these, the “differentiator” is likely marketing language rather than operational reality. The 90-day recency matters because TikTok Shop changes fast—a case study from a year ago may reflect a different algorithm and a different competitive environment.

Why you must interview the account manager before signing

my second filter is the account manager call:

“Ask who the AM will be on your account and their background. You MUST get on a call with the AM who will be working with you and run them through a short interview for 30 mins on TikTok Shop strategies for your brand.”

This single step screens out agencies that charge premium prices but assign junior operators. The brand gets to hear how the AM thinks about creator outreach, sampling, content iteration, and GMV Max—before any money changes hands.

“This will let you easily screen out junior AM’s from agency’s who charge premium prices before you sign a contract.”

How thought leadership signals competence

my third filter is public content:

“If an agency has no quality content or voice around TikTok Shop then I’m hesitant that they know what they’re talking about.”

TikTok Shop requires significant upfront investment. Brands need confidence that the agency understands where to allocate that spend and can adapt to algorithmic shifts. Public thought leadership—podcasts, LinkedIn posts, breakdowns of real campaigns—provides evidence of that understanding.

“TikTok Shop is a channel where you have to invest a ton of cash upfront for a long period of time. I want to know that my agency understands where to put that investment and is on top of all algorithmic shifts/market data so I give my brand the best shot.”

Why community management skill matters more than ad buying

On the Reacher podcast, I pushed back on the instinct to hire ad buyers first:

“I don’t think you need an ads guy because you shouldn’t spend money on ads until you have a sizable enough community.”

This has implications for agency selection. An agency that leads with GMV Max expertise but lacks a clear community-building system may be optimizing the wrong part of the funnel. I explained why:

“Until you have enough volume of content your GMV max campaigns will never be successful no matter how good your ad guy is because the game is 3% how good are you at buying the ads 97% how good are you at getting content and what is the quality of the content.”

Brands evaluating agencies should ask how the agency sources, briefs, and manages creators—not just how it manages ad spend.

What community coordinators need to succeed

I described the personality traits that make community coordinators effective:

“The number one skill to have is patience, right? Like you really got to be patient.”

He also highlighted the importance of sociability and the ability to handle questions:

“How sociable they are, right? Like you know, do they have a lot to say? Are they, you know, willing to talk? Can they talk about stuff they don’t know about? I think that’s something to know, right? Because like again, creators are gonna ask them a ton of questions.”

When evaluating an agency, brands can ask to meet the community coordinator or manager who will handle their creator relationships. The same 30-minute interview I recommend for the AM applies here.

Key takeaways

• Verify differentiators with specifics: proprietary tech, an engaged creator community of 200–300 in your niche, or a case study from the last 90 days.
• Interview the actual account manager for 30 minutes on TikTok Shop strategies before signing any contract.
• Confirm the agency publishes quality thought leadership that demonstrates understanding of algorithmic shifts and market data.
• Prioritize agencies with strong community management systems—“the game is 3% how good are you at buying the ads 97% how good are you at getting content.”
• Ask to meet the community coordinator and assess patience, sociability, and ability to handle creator questions.

What this means for operators

Brands burned by agencies usually skipped the vetting steps I outlined. The framework is simple:

“Ask what their differentiator is… Ask who the AM will be on your account and their background… Content and thought leadership.”

Running these three checks before signing a contract costs nothing and screens out the agencies that look good on paper but fail in execution.

---

Sources

1. TikTok Shop Agency Selection Framework | Sohun Sanka posted on the topic | LinkedIn
2. TikTok Shop Agency Selection Framework | Sohun Sanka posted on the topic | LinkedIn
3. TikTok Shop Agency Selection Framework | Sohun Sanka posted on the topic | LinkedIn
4. TikTok Shop Agency Selection Framework | Sohun Sanka posted on the topic | LinkedIn
5. TikTok Shop Agency Selection Framework | Sohun Sanka posted on the topic | LinkedIn
6. TikTok Shop Agency Selection Framework | Sohun Sanka posted on the topic | LinkedIn
7. TikTok Shop Agency Selection Framework | Sohun Sanka posted on the topic | LinkedIn
8. Jay Hunter Spills the Secret Sauce Behind Mary Ruth's TikTok Shop Strategy
9. Jay Hunter Spills the Secret Sauce Behind Mary Ruth's TikTok Shop Strategy
10. Jay Hunter Spills the Secret Sauce Behind Mary Ruth's TikTok Shop Strategy
11. Jay Hunter Spills the Secret Sauce Behind Mary Ruth's TikTok Shop Strategy
12. TikTok Shop Agency Selection Framework | Sohun Sanka posted on the topic | LinkedIn